I thought they came out kind of even.
Neither of them had anything really great to say. They both had moments where they looked good, and moments where they looked bad. I don't think Trump was nearly as incoherent as some people are saying, frankly I just think they weren't listening. Then again, I've been listening to all of these speeches for over a year now, so I'm familiar with the way these people speak and phrase their thoughts.
On Hillary's side, I don't think she was anywhere near as strong as some outlets are spinning it today. She seemed tired most of the time and her energy didn't stack up against her opponent. That said, she definitely gave off more experience in this specific field; however, I'm not sure which one I think could handle people better. They're both mother****ers to have gotten where they are, so I think this category is a bit of a wash.
But Hillary once again came off very condescending, which is a major turn-off for me, but it's no secret that she's the most politically-qualified person on the stage. Trump was blustery and too unfocused, not good skills for the Presidency, but I still like some of his approach and what it does to the establishment. Trump had a few statements against Hillary that were absolutely devastating and she never really came up with much to match that, outside of the tired (lol) "you're lying" shtick.
The spin will determine the win.
My plan is to commit suicide on election day so I don't have to actually vote. Gonna put my insides on the outside for America!